Stories

The fragrances players mix up most often

Across 196 revealed puzzles, players who finished on the day made 4,432 wrong guesses. 16% of them named a fragrance from the answer’s own house. The most common: 12 players guessed Myslf when the answer was Y.

Most common wrong guesses PLAYERS

  1. Myslf when the answer was Y 12 Both Yves Saint Laurent · 50% of 24 finishes over 2 puzzles
  2. Vibrato when the answer was Basso 10 Both Sospiro · 59% of 17 finishes over 2 puzzles
  3. Mahina when the answer was Kaya 8 Both Parfums d'Elmar · 32% of 25 finishes over 3 puzzles
  4. Aventus when the answer was Hacivat 8 Creed, answer by Nishane · 28% of 29 finishes over 2 puzzles
  5. Ani when the answer was Nefs 7 Both Nishane · 50% of 14 finishes
  6. Zaya when the answer was Yaringa 7 Both Parfums d'Elmar · 37% of 19 finishes over 2 puzzles
  7. Erba Pura when the answer was Erba Gold 6 Both XerJoff · 29% of 21 finishes
  8. Naxos when the answer was Ambre Superfluide 6 XerJoff, answer by Les Eaux Primordiales · 27% of 22 finishes over 2 puzzles
  9. Emporio Armani - Stronger With You Absolutely when the answer was Emporio Armani - Stronger with You Intensely 6 Both Giorgio Armani · 18% of 34 finishes over 3 puzzles
  10. Vanilla Diorama when the answer was Hibiscus MahaJád 6 Dior, answer by Maison Crivelli · 13% of 45 finishes

Right house, wrong bottle

714 of 4,432 wrong guesses (16%) named a fragrance from the answer’s own house. The rest went to another house entirely.

  • Same house as the answer 16%
  • Another house 84%

Houses players reach for WRONG GUESSES

When the answer came from another house, these were the houses players named most.

  1. Dior 225 on 90 puzzles
  2. Tom Ford 204 on 97 puzzles
  3. Yves Saint Laurent 168 on 81 puzzles
  4. Louis Vuitton 134 on 68 puzzles
  5. Giorgio Armani 132 on 71 puzzles
  6. Jean Paul Gaultier 124 on 70 puzzles
  7. Parfums de Marly 116 on 62 puzzles
  8. Chanel 102 on 61 puzzles

Houses players mix up WRONG GUESSES

One house guessed when the answer came from another, counted over at least three puzzles of the answer’s house.

  1. Dior when the answer was by Mancera 20 over 3 puzzles with a Mancera answer
  2. Dior when the answer was by Parfums de Marly 17 over 9 puzzles with a Parfums de Marly answer
  3. Dior when the answer was by Maison Crivelli 15 over 3 puzzles with a Maison Crivelli answer
  4. Yves Saint Laurent when the answer was by Maison Crivelli 13 over 3 puzzles with a Maison Crivelli answer
  5. Yves Saint Laurent when the answer was by Parfums de Marly 13 over 6 puzzles with a Parfums de Marly answer
  6. Giorgio Armani when the answer was by XerJoff 13 over 5 puzzles with a XerJoff answer
  7. Yves Saint Laurent when the answer was by Maison Francis Kurkdjian 12 over 4 puzzles with a Maison Francis Kurkdjian answer
  8. Parfums de Marly when the answer was by Parfums d'Elmar 12 over 4 puzzles with a Parfums d'Elmar answer

How this is counted

Wrong guesses by players who finished a puzzle on its day (within 26 hours of the puzzle’s UTC day), over every puzzle whose answer is public, which is every puzzle older than a week. Skips are not guesses. Nobody can guess the same fragrance twice in one game, so a count of guesses is a count of players. A guess of another listing of the same fragrance (same house, same name apart from the concentration) is not counted as a mix-up. A pair is listed from 4 players, a house pair from 3 puzzles. Test and staff accounts are left out. These are game facts about what players typed, not a statement about how the fragrances smell.

More stories

Play today's Scentle: name one fragrance from its notes in six guesses.